NOGRR #215 · Revision Request
NOGRR215 Limit Use of Remedial Action Schemes
ReasonAddresses current operational issues
Created2020-07-09
Approved2023-10-12
Sections Affected
8K11.111.211.2.1
Summary
This Nodal Operating Guide Revision Request (NOGRR) will allow new Remedial Action Schemes (RASs) to be used only to address an actual or anticipated violation of transmission security criteria when market tools are insufficient to address those violations. This NOGRR also clarifies the procedures for retiring RASs.
Action Log 8 milestones
-
Jul 9
ROSDeferred/Tabled→ Language Consideration
-
Mar 2
ROSRecommended for Approval→ Impact Analysis Consideration
-
Apr 6
ROSDeferred/Tabled→ Impact Analysis Consideration
-
Jul 6
ROSDeferred/Tabled→ Impact Analysis Consideration
-
Aug 3
ROSRecommended for Approval→ Revision Request Consideration
-
Aug 22
TACRecommended for Approval→ Revision Request Consideration
-
Aug 31
BOARDRecommended for Approval→ Revision Request Consideration
-
Oct 12
PUCTApproved
Amendments
| Date | Body | Motion | Result |
|---|---|---|---|
| Mar 2 '23 | ROS | to recommend approval of NOGRR215 as amended by the 3/1/23 LCRA comments as revised by ROS | Passed |
| Aug 3 '23 | ROS | to endorse and forward to TAC the 7/6/23 ROS Report as amended by the 7/31/23 ERCOT comments and 7/10/23 Revised Impact Analysis for NOGRR215 with a recommended priority of 2026 and rank of 4700 | Passed |
| Aug 22 '23 | TAC | to recommend approval of NOGRR215 as recommended by ROS in the 8/3/23 ROS Report as revised by TAC; with a recommended effective date of 10/1/23 for all sections except greyboxed paragraph (3) of Section 11.1 and paragraph (1) of Section 11.2 and which will be effective upon system implementation | Passed |
Ballots
| Date | Body | Result | Yes | No | Abstain | |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Aug 22 '23 | TAC | Motion Passes | 29 | 0 | 0 | xls |
| Aug 10 '23 | PRS | Motion Carries | 7 | 0 | 0 | xls |
| Jul 6 '23 | ROS | Motion Carries | 7.5 | 0 | 0 | xls |
| Apr 6 '23 | ROS | Motion Carries | 7.5 | 0 | 1 | xls |
| Mar 2 '23 | ROS | Motion Carries | 6 | 0.75 | 7 | xls |
| Jul 9 '20 | ROS | Motion Carries | 7.5 | 0 | 0 | xls |
Documents 39
| Name | Type | Posted | Classification |
|---|---|---|---|
| 215NOGRR-01 Limit Use of Remedial Action Schemes 062420 | doc | Jun 24 '20 | Revision Request |
| 215NOGRR-02 Impact Analysis 062420 | doc | Jun 24 '20 | Staff Report |
| 215NOGRR-03 ROS Ballot 070920 | xls | Jul 13 '20 | Revision Request Ballot |
| 215NOGRR-04 ROS Report 070920 | doc | Jul 13 '20 | Committee Report |
| 215NOGRR-05 WMS Ballot 070820 | xls | Jul 14 '20 | Revision Request Ballot |
| 215NOGRR-06 WMS Comments 071420 | doc | Jul 14 '20 | Revision Request Comments |
| 215NOGRR-07 Joint Commenters Comments 010821 | docx | Jan 8 '21 | Revision Request Comments |
| 215NOGRR-08 DME Comments 011121 | docx | Jan 11 '21 | Revision Request Comments |
| 215NOGRR-09 Revised Impact Analysis 080421 | doc | Aug 4 '21 | Staff Report |
| 215NOGRR-10 ERCOT Comments 051822 | doc | May 18 '22 | Revision Request Comments |
| 215NOGRR-11 LCRA Comments 053122 | doc | May 31 '22 | Revision Request Comments |
| 215NOGRR-12 Lancium Comments 060122 | doc | Jun 1 '22 | Revision Request Comments |
| 215NOGRR-13 LCRA and Luminant Comments 083122 | doc | Aug 31 '22 | Revision Request Comments |
| 215NOGRR-14 LCRA Comments 010323 | docx | Jan 3 '23 | Revision Request Comments |
| 215NOGRR-15 LCRA Comments 013123 | doc | Jan 31 '23 | Revision Request Comments |
| 215NOGRR-16 AEP Comments 013123 | doc | Jan 31 '23 | Revision Request Comments |
| 215NOGRR-17 LCRA Comments_030123 | doc | Mar 1 '23 | Revision Request Comments |
| 215NOGRR-18 AEP Comments 030123 | doc | Mar 1 '23 | Revision Request Comments |
| 215NOGRR-19 STEC Comments 030123 | doc | Mar 1 '23 | Revision Request Comments |
| 215NOGRR-20 ROS Ballot 030223 | xls | Mar 7 '23 | Revision Request Ballot |
| 215NOGRR-21 ROS Report 030223 | doc | Mar 7 '23 | Committee Report |
| 215NOGRR-22 ERCOT Comments 032723 | doc | Mar 27 '23 | Revision Request Comments |
| 215NOGRR-23 ROS Ballot 040623 | xls | Apr 10 '23 | Revision Request Ballot |
| 215NOGRR-24 ROS Report 040623 | doc | Apr 10 '23 | Committee Report |
| 215NOGRR-25 ERCOT Comments 042523 | doc | Apr 25 '23 | Revision Request Comments |
| 215NOGRR-26 ERCOT Comments 060723 | doc | Jun 7 '23 | Revision Request Comments |
| 215NOGRR-27 Revised Impact Analysis 062723 | docx | Jun 27 '23 | Staff Report |
| 215NOGRR-28 ROS Ballot 070623 | xls | Jul 10 '23 | Revision Request Ballot |
| 215NOGRR-29 ROS Report 070623 | doc | Jul 10 '23 | Committee Report |
| 215NOGRR-30 Revised Impact Analysis 071023 | docx | Jul 10 '23 | Staff Report |
| 215NOGRR-31 ERCOT Comments_073123 | doc | Jul 31 '23 | Revision Request Comments |
| 215NOGRR-32 ROS Ballot 080323 | xls | Aug 7 '23 | Revision Request Ballot |
| 215NOGRR-33 ROS Report 080323 | doc | Aug 7 '23 | Committee Report |
| 215NOGRR-34 PRS Ballot 081023 | xls | Aug 11 '23 | Revision Request Ballot |
| 215NOGRR-35 PRS Comments 081123 | docx | Aug 11 '23 | Revision Request Comments |
| 215NOGRR-36 TAC Ballot_082223 | xls | Aug 22 '23 | Revision Request Ballot |
| 215NOGRR-37 TAC Report 082223 | doc | Aug 22 '23 | Committee Report |
| 215NOGRR-38 Board Report 083123 | doc | Sep 5 '23 | Committee Report |
| 215NOGRR-39 PUCT Report 101223 | doc | Oct 16 '23 | Committee Report |
Meetings That Took It Up 108
| Date | Meeting | Committee | Status |
|---|---|---|---|
| Aug 31 '23 | Board of Directors Meeting | BOARD | Concluded |
| Aug 22 '23 | TAC Meeting - Webex Only | TAC | Concluded |
| Aug 10 '23 | PRS Meeting | PRS | Concluded |
| Aug 3 '23 | ROS Meeting | ROS | Concluded |
| Aug 2 '23 | WMS Meeting - Webex Only | WMS | Concluded |
| Jul 12 '23 | WMS Meeting | WMS | Concluded |
| Jul 6 '23 | ROS Meeting - Webex Only | ROS | Concluded |
| Jun 8 '23 | ROS Meeting | ROS | Concluded |
| Jun 7 '23 | WMS Meeting | WMS | Concluded |
| May 4 '23 | ROS Meeting - Webex Only | ROS | Concluded |
| May 3 '23 | WMS Meeting - Webex Only | WMS | Concluded |
| Apr 6 '23 | ROS Meeting | ROS | Concluded |
| Apr 5 '23 | WMS Meeting | WMS | Concluded |
| Mar 2 '23 | ROS Meeting | ROS | Concluded |
| Mar 1 '23 | WMS Meeting | WMS | Concluded |
| Feb 8 '23 | ROS Meeting - Webex Only | ROS | Concluded |
| Feb 6 '23 | WMS Meeting - Webex Only | WMS | Concluded |
| Feb 1 '23 | WMS Meeting - Webex Only (RESCHEDULED) | WMS | Rescheduled |
| Jan 19 '23 | OWG Meeting - Webex Only | OWG | Concluded |
| Jan 11 '23 | WMS Meeting | WMS | Concluded |
| Jan 5 '23 | ROS Meeting | ROS | Concluded |
| Dec 16 '22 | OWG Meeting by Webex Only | OWG | Concluded |
| Dec 1 '22 | ROS Meeting by Webex Only | ROS | Concluded |
| Nov 17 '22 | OWG Meeting by Webex Only | OWG | Concluded |
| Nov 7 '22 | ROS Meeting by Webex Only | ROS | Concluded |
| Nov 2 '22 | WMS Meeting by Webex Only | WMS | Concluded |
| Oct 27 '22 | OWG Meeting by Webex Only | OWG | Concluded |
| Oct 12 '22 | WMS Meeting | WMS | Concluded |
| Sep 29 '22 | ROS Meeting by Webex Only | ROS | Concluded |
| Sep 22 '22 | OWG Meeting by Webex Only | OWG | Concluded |
| Sep 7 '22 | WMS Meeting | WMS | Concluded |
| Sep 1 '22 | ROS Meeting | ROS | Concluded |
| Aug 18 '22 | OWG Meeting by Webex Only | OWG | Concluded |
| Aug 10 '22 | ROS Meeting | ROS | Concluded |
| Aug 3 '22 | WMS Meeting | WMS | Concluded |
| Jul 21 '22 | OWG Meeting by Webex Only | OWG | Concluded |
| Jun 23 '22 | OWG Meeting by Webex Only | OWG | Concluded |
| Jun 13 '22 | CMWG by Webex Only | CMWG | Concluded |
| Jun 2 '22 | ROS Meeting | ROS | Concluded |
| Jun 1 '22 | WMS Meeting | WMS | Concluded |
| May 19 '22 | OWG Meeting by Webex Only | OWG | Concluded |
| May 5 '22 | ROS Meeting | ROS | Concluded |
| May 4 '22 | WMS Meeting | WMS | Concluded |
| Apr 21 '22 | OWG Meeting by Webex Only | OWG | Concluded |
| Apr 7 '22 | ROS Meeting | ROS | Concluded |
| Apr 6 '22 | WMS Meeting | WMS | Concluded |
| Mar 24 '22 | OWG Meeting by Webex Only | OWG | Concluded |
| Mar 3 '22 | ROS Meeting by Webex Only | ROS | Concluded |
| Mar 2 '22 | WMS Meeting by Webex Only | WMS | Concluded |
| Feb 17 '22 | OWG Meeting by Webex Only | OWG | Concluded |
| Feb 7 '22 | ROS Meeting by Webex Only | ROS | Concluded |
| Feb 2 '22 | WMS Meeting by Webex Only | WMS | Concluded |
| Jan 20 '22 | OWG Meeting by Webex Only | OWG | Concluded |
| Jan 6 '22 | ROS Meeting by Webex Only | ROS | Concluded |
| Jan 5 '22 | WMS Meeting by Webex Only | WMS | Concluded |
| Dec 16 '21 | OWG Meeting by Webex Only | OWG | Concluded |
| Dec 2 '21 | ROS Meeting by Webex Only | ROS | Concluded |
| Dec 1 '21 | WMS Meeting by Webex Only | WMS | Concluded |
| Nov 18 '21 | OWG Meeting by Webex Only | OWG | Concluded |
| Nov 4 '21 | ROS Meeting by Webex Only | ROS | Concluded |
| Nov 3 '21 | WMS Meeting by Webex Only | WMS | Concluded |
| Oct 21 '21 | OWG Meeting by Webex Only | OWG | Concluded |
| Oct 7 '21 | ROS Meeting by Webex Only | ROS | Concluded |
| Oct 6 '21 | WMS Meeting by Webex Only | WMS | Concluded |
| Sep 14 '21 | OWG Meeting by Webex Only | OWG | Concluded |
| Sep 2 '21 | ROS Meeting by Webex Only | ROS | Concluded |
| Sep 1 '21 | WMS Meeting by Webex Only | WMS | Concluded |
| Aug 19 '21 | OWG Meeting by Webex Only | OWG | Concluded |
| Aug 5 '21 | ROS Meeting by Webex Only | ROS | Concluded |
| Aug 4 '21 | WMS Meeting by Webex Only | WMS | Concluded |
| Jul 13 '21 | OWG Meeting by Webex Only | OWG | Concluded |
| Jul 8 '21 | ROS Meeting by Webex Only | ROS | Concluded |
| Jul 7 '21 | WMS Meeting by Webex Only | WMS | Concluded |
| Jun 17 '21 | OWG Meeting by Webex Only | OWG | Concluded |
| Jun 3 '21 | ROS Meeting by Webex Only | ROS | Concluded |
| Jun 2 '21 | WMS Meeting by Webex Only | WMS | Concluded |
| May 27 '21 | OWG Meeting by Webex Only | OWG | Concluded |
| May 5 '21 | WMS Meeting by Webex Only | WMS | Concluded |
| Apr 29 '21 | ROS Meeting by Webex Only | ROS | Concluded |
| Apr 16 '21 | OWG Meeting by Webex Only | OWG | Concluded |
| Apr 7 '21 | WMS Meeting by Webex Only | WMS | Concluded |
| Apr 1 '21 | ROS Meeting by Webex Only | ROS | Concluded |
| Mar 18 '21 | OWG Meeting by Webex Only | OWG | Concluded |
| Mar 4 '21 | ROS Meeting by Webex Only | ROS | Concluded |
| Feb 4 '21 | ROS Meeting by Webex Only | ROS | Concluded |
| Feb 3 '21 | WMS Meeting by Webex Only | WMS | Concluded |
| Jan 21 '21 | OWG Meeting by Webex Only | OWG | Concluded |
| Jan 11 '21 | CMWG Meeting by Webex Only | CMWG | Concluded |
| Jan 7 '21 | ROS Meeting by Webex Only | ROS | Concluded |
| Jan 6 '21 | WMS Meeting by Webex Only | WMS | Concluded |
| Dec 17 '20 | OWG Meeting by Webex Only | OWG | Concluded |
| Dec 3 '20 | ROS Meeting by Webex Only | ROS | Concluded |
| Dec 2 '20 | WMS Meeting by Webex Only | WMS | Concluded |
| Nov 19 '20 | OWG Meeting by Webex Only | OWG | Concluded |
| Nov 5 '20 | ROS Meeting by Webex Only | ROS | Concluded |
| Nov 4 '20 | WMS Meeting by Webex Only | WMS | Concluded |
| Nov 2 '20 | CMWG Meeting by Webex Only | CMWG | Concluded |
| Oct 23 '20 | OWG Meeting by Webex Only | OWG | Concluded |
| Oct 19 '20 | PLWG Meeting by Webex Only | PLWG | Concluded |
| Oct 8 '20 | ROS Meeting by Webex Only | ROS | Concluded |
| Oct 7 '20 | WMS Meeting by Webex Only | WMS | Concluded |
| Sep 3 '20 | ROS Meeting | ROS | Concluded |
| Sep 2 '20 | WMS Meeting | WMS | Concluded |
| Aug 21 '20 | Transmission Issues Related to Generation Constraints Workshop by Webex Only | Concluded | |
| Aug 6 '20 | ROS Meeting | ROS | Concluded |
| Aug 5 '20 | WMS Meeting | WMS | Concluded |
| Jul 9 '20 | ROS Meeting | ROS | Concluded |
| Jul 8 '20 | WMS Meeting | WMS | Concluded |