NPRR #1247 · Revision Request
NPRR1247 Incorporation of Congestion Cost Savings Test in Economic Evaluation of Transmission Projects
ReasonRegulatory requirements
Created2024-09-12
Approved2025-01-16
Sections Affected
3.11.2
Summary
This Nodal Protocol Revision Request (NPRR) incorporates the consumer energy cost reduction test as the congestion cost savings test in economic project evaluation to address recent amendments by the PUCT to 16 Texas Administrative Code (TAC) § 25.101 —specifically adding the requirements in § 25.101(b)(3)(A)(i). Consistent with the PUCT’s rule, this NPRR also preserves the production cost savings test as another standalone means to establish economic need for a transmission project. This NPRR also removes obsolete language regarding transmission projects’ benefits evaluation in paragraph (6) of Section 3.11.2. Additional details regarding how the congestion cost savings test will be performed are included in the Congestion Cost Savings Test Evaluation Guideline white paper, which will be available on the Planning page of the ERCOT website once finalized. ERCOT may also apply the longstanding Impact of Weather Uncertainty and Transmission Outages on Economic Project Evaluations white paper in the instances specified therein to evaluate the impact of weather uncertainties and the impact of including transmission outages on the congestion cost savings test, as it has for the production cost savings test. This white paper is also available on the Planning page of the ERCOT website.
Action Log 5 milestones
-
Sep 12
PRSDeferred/Tabled→ Language Consideration
-
Nov 14
PRSRecommended for Approval→ Revision Request Consideration
-
Nov 20
TACRecommended for Approval→ Revision Request Consideration
-
Dec 3
BOARDRecommended for Approval→ Revision Request Consideration
-
Jan 16
PUCTApproved
Amendments
| Date | Body | Motion | Result |
|---|---|---|---|
| Nov 14 '24 | PRS | to grant NPRR1247 Urgent status; to recommend approval of NPRR1247 as amended by the 11/11/24 ERCOT comments; and to forward to TAC NPRR1247 and the 8/9/24 Impact Analysis | Passed |
Ballots
| Date | Body | Result | Yes | No | Abstain | |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Nov 20 '24 | TAC | Motion Passes | 25 | 3 | 1 | xls |
| Nov 20 '24 | TAC | Motion Fails | 11 | 17 | 1 | xls |
| Nov 14 '24 | PRS | Motion Carries | 4.33333 | 0.666667 | 4 | xls |
| Nov 7 '24 | ROS | Motion Carries | 5 | 1.5 | 11 | xls |
| Oct 3 '24 | ROS | Motion Carries | 7.5 | 0 | 0 | xls |
| Sep 12 '24 | PRS | Motion Carries | 7 | 0 | 0 | xls |
Documents 27
| Name | Type | Posted | Classification |
|---|---|---|---|
| 1247NPRR-01 Incorporation of Congestion Cost Savings Test in Economic Evaluation of Transmission Projects 080924 | docx | Aug 9 '24 | Revision Request |
| 1247NPRR-02 Impact Analysis 080924 | docx | Aug 9 '24 | Staff Report |
| 1247NPRR-03 TIEC Comments 091124 | docx | Sep 11 '24 | Revision Request Comments |
| 1247NPRR-04 PRS Ballot 091224 | xls | Sep 16 '24 | Revision Request Ballot |
| 1247NPRR-05 PRS Report 091224 | docx | Sep 16 '24 | Committee Report |
| 1247NPRR-06 AEPSC Comments 100324 | docx | Oct 3 '24 | Revision Request Comments |
| 1247NPRR-07 ROS Ballot 100324 | xls | Oct 4 '24 | Revision Request Ballot |
| 1247NPRR-08 ROS Comments 100424 | docx | Oct 4 '24 | Revision Request Comments |
| 1247NPRR-09 ERCOT Comments 101124 | docx | Oct 11 '24 | Revision Request Comments |
| 1247NPRR-10 Joint Commenters Comments 101524 | docx | Oct 15 '24 | Revision Request Comments |
| 1247NPRR-11 Reliant Comments 101824 | docx | Oct 18 '24 | Revision Request Comments |
| 1247NPRR-12 Joint Commenters Comments 102324 | docx | Oct 23 '24 | Revision Request Comments |
| 1247NPRR-13 ERCOT Comments 102324 | docx | Oct 23 '24 | Revision Request Comments |
| 1247NPRR-14 Luminant Comments 102824 | docx | Oct 28 '24 | Revision Request Comments |
| 1247NPRR-15 ERCOT Comments 110124 | docx | Nov 1 '24 | Revision Request Comments |
| 1247NPRR-16 ROS Ballot 110724 | xls | Nov 8 '24 | Revision Request Ballot |
| 1247NPRR-17 ROS Comments 110824 | docx | Nov 8 '24 | Revision Request Comments |
| 1247NPRR-18 ERCOT Comments 111124 | docx | Nov 11 '24 | Revision Request Comments |
| 1247NPRR-19 PRS Ballot 111424 | xls | Nov 15 '24 | Revision Request Ballot |
| 1247NPRR-20 PRS Report 111424 | docx | Nov 15 '24 | Committee Report |
| 1247NPRR-21 Luminant Comments 111524 | docx | Nov 15 '24 | Revision Request Comments |
| 1247NPRR-22 ERCOT Comments 111924 | docx | Nov 19 '24 | Revision Request Comments |
| 1247NPRR-23 TAC Ballot 112024 | xls | Nov 22 '24 | Revision Request Ballot |
| 1247NPRR-24 TAC Report 112024 | docx | Nov 22 '24 | Committee Report |
| 1247NPRR-25 ERCOT Comments 112624 | docx | Nov 26 '24 | Revision Request Comments |
| 1247NPRR-26 Board Report 120324 | docx | Dec 5 '24 | Committee Report |
| 1247NPRR-27 PUCT Report 011625 | docx | Jan 21 '25 | Committee Report |
Meetings That Took It Up 12
| Date | Meeting | Committee | Status |
|---|---|---|---|
| Dec 3 '24 | Board of Directors Meeting | BOARD | Concluded |
| Dec 2 '24 | Reliability and Markets Committee Meeting | RELIABILITYMARKETS | Concluded |
| Nov 20 '24 | TAC Meeting | TAC | Concluded |
| Nov 14 '24 | PRS Meeting | PRS | Concluded |
| Nov 12 '24 | PLWG Meeting | PLWG | Concluded |
| Nov 7 '24 | ROS Meeting | ROS | Concluded |
| Oct 29 '24 | Special PLWG - Webex Only | PLWG | Concluded |
| Oct 17 '24 | PRS Meeting | PRS | Concluded |
| Oct 16 '24 | PLWG Meeting | PLWG | Concluded |
| Oct 3 '24 | ROS Meeting - Webex Only | ROS | Concluded |
| Sep 24 '24 | PLWG - Webex Only | PLWG | Concluded |
| Sep 12 '24 | PRS Meeting | PRS | Concluded |