ERCOT·WATCH Search ercot.com  ⌕
NPRR #649 · Revision Request

NPRR649  Addressing Issues Surrounding High Dispatch Limit (HDL) Overrides

Approved sponsor ERCOT posted 2014-09-12 ercot.com
ReasonSubmitted pursuant to settlement agreement.
Created2014-10-09
Approved2016-04-19
Rejected2015-11-19
Sections Affected
1.3.1.14.6.56.5.7.1.106.5.7.1.136.6.3.9 (new)6.6.3.10 (new)6.6.5.19.5.3
Summary
This Nodal Protocol Revision Request (NPRR) proposes a compensation mechanism for Generation Resources that are issued a High Dispatch Limit (HDL) manual override that results in a real power reduction (subject to certain criteria). The proposed mechanism compensates the Qualified Scheduling Entity (QSE) for financial loss associated with variable cost components of Day-Ahead Market (DAM) obligations or bilateral contracts arising from the HDL manual override. ERCOT submits this NPRR to satisfy its obligations under a settlement agreement reached with Odessa Ector Power Partners, LP in Public Utility Commission of Texas (PUCT) Docket 41790. ERCOT’s submission of this NPRR does not imply ERCOT’s support for or opposition to the principles stated in this NPRR.
Action Log 12 milestones
Amendments
DateBodyMotionResult
Jun 11 '15PRS To recommend approval of NPRR649 as amended by the 6/4/15 WMS commentsPassed
Oct 15 '15PRS To endorse the 8/13/15 PRS Report as amended by the 9/30/15 ERCOT comments; and requested a revised Impact Analysis be brought back to PRS for considerationPassed
Nov 12 '15PRS To endorse and forward to TAC the 10/15/15 PRS Report as amended by the 11/11/15 Odessa-Ector comments and the revised Impact Analysis for NPRR649 with a recommended priority of 2016 and rank of 1520Passed
Nov 19 '15TAC To recommend approval of NPRR649 as recommended by PRS in the 11/12/15 PRS Report and as revised by TACFailed
Mar 31 '16TAC To recommend approval of NPRR649 as recommended by PRS in the 11/12/15 PRS Report and as amended by the 2/22/16 ERCOT commentsPassed
Apr 19 '16BOARD To approve NPRR649 as recommended by TAC in the 3/31/16 TAC Report and as amended by the 4/7/16 ERCOT commentsPassed
Documents 38
NameTypePostedClassification
649NPRR-01 Lost Opportunity Payments for HDL Manual Overrides 091214 doc Sep 12 '14 Revision Request
649NPRR-02 Impact Analysis 091214 doc Sep 12 '14 Staff Report
649NPRR-03 PRS Report 100914 doc Oct 13 '14 Committee Report
649NPRR-04 Odessa Comments 102814 doc Oct 28 '14 Revision Request Comments
649NPRR-05 WMS Comments 120814 doc Dec 8 '14 Revision Request Comments
649NPRR-06 PRS Report 031215 doc Mar 16 '15 Committee Report
649NPRR-07 WMS Comments 040715 doc Apr 7 '15 Revision Request Comments
649NPRR-08 Odessa Comments 042415 doc Apr 24 '15 Revision Request Comments
649NPRR-09 WMS Comments 060415 doc Jun 4 '15 Revision Request Comments
649NPRR-10 PRS Report 061115 doc Jun 15 '15 Committee Report
649NPRR-11 PRS Voting Ballot 061115 xls Jun 15 '15 Revision Request Ballot
649NPRR-12 Odessa Comments 070615 doc Jul 6 '15 Revision Request Comments
649NPRR-13 Revised Impact Analysis 070915 doc Jul 9 '15 Staff Report
649NPRR-14 Revised Impact Analysis 071515 doc Jul 15 '15 Staff Report
649NPRR-15 PRS Report 071615 doc Jul 20 '15 Committee Report
649NPRR-16 PRS Report 081315 doc Aug 17 '15 Committee Report
649NPRR-17 ERCOT Comments 093015 doc Sep 30 '15 Revision Request Comments
649NPRR-18 WMS Comments 100815 doc Oct 8 '15 Revision Request Comments
649NPRR-19 PRS Report 101515 doc Oct 19 '15 Committee Report
649NPRR-20 Revised Impact Analysis 102815 doc Oct 28 '15 Staff Report
649NPRR-21 Odessa Comments 111115 doc Nov 11 '15 Revision Request Comments
649NPRR-22 PRS Report 111215 doc Nov 13 '15 Committee Report
649NPRR-23 TAC Report 111915 doc Nov 20 '15 Committee Report
649NPRR-24 TAC Voting Ballot 111915 xls Nov 20 '15 Revision Request Ballot
649NPRR-25(a) Koch Ag & Energy Solutions Appeal 120715 doc Dec 9 '15 Legal filings and governance
649NPRR-26(a) Koch Ag & Energy Solutions Position Statement 020216 doc Feb 3 '16 Revision Request Comments
649NPRR-26(b) Koch Ag & Energy Solutions Board Presentation 020216 pptx Feb 3 '16 Stakeholder Presentation
649NPRR-27 TAC Advocate Presentation of TAC Action 020216 pptx Feb 3 '16 Stakeholder Presentation
649NPRR-28 STEC & Golden Spread Position Statement 020216 doc Feb 3 '16 Revision Request Comments
649NPRR-30 Board Report 020916 doc Feb 10 '16 Committee Report
649NPRR-31 ERCOT Comments 022216 doc Feb 22 '16 Revision Request Comments
649NPRR-32 TAC Report 022516 doc Mar 1 '16 Committee Report
649NPRR-33 ERCOT Comments 032416 doc Mar 24 '16 Revision Request Comments
649NPRR-34 TAC Report 033116 doc Apr 1 '16 Committee Report
649NPRR-35 TAC Voting Ballot 033116 xls Apr 1 '16 Revision Request Ballot
649NPRR-36 Revised Impact Analysis 040616 doc Apr 6 '16 Staff Report
649NPRR-37 ERCOT Comments 040716 doc Apr 7 '16 Revision Request Comments
649NPRR-38 Board Report 041916 doc Apr 20 '16 Committee Report
Meetings That Took It Up 34
DateMeetingCommitteeStatus
Apr 19 '16 Board of Directors Meeting BOARD Concluded
Mar 31 '16 TAC Meeting TAC Concluded
Mar 11 '16 NPRR649 WebEx Workshop III Concluded
Feb 25 '16 TAC Meeting TAC Concluded
Feb 9 '16 Board of Directors Meeting BOARD Concluded
Nov 19 '15 TAC Meeting TAC Concluded
Nov 12 '15 PRS Meeting PRS Concluded
Oct 15 '15 PRS Meeting PRS Concluded
Oct 7 '15 WMS Meeting WMS Concluded
Sep 10 '15 PRS Meeting PRS Concluded
Sep 2 '15 WMS Meeting WMS Concluded
Aug 13 '15 PRS Meeting PRS Concluded
Jul 16 '15 PRS Meeting PRS Concluded
Jun 17 '15 CWG/MCWG Meeting (CANCELLED) CREDITWG Cancelled
Jun 11 '15 PRS Meeting PRS Concluded
Jun 3 '15 WMS Meeting WMS Concluded
May 14 '15 PRS Meeting PRS Concluded
Apr 16 '15 PRS Meeting PRS Concluded
Apr 10 '15 QMWG Meeting QMWG Concluded
Apr 6 '15 WMS Meeting WMS Concluded
Mar 12 '15 PRS Meeting PRS Concluded
Feb 12 '15 PRS Meeting PRS Concluded
Feb 4 '15 WMS Meeting WMS Concluded
Jan 15 '15 PRS Meeting PRS Concluded
Jan 7 '15 WMS Meeting WMS Concluded
Jan 7 '15 NPRR649 Workshop WORKSHOPS Concluded
Dec 11 '14 PRS Meeting PRS Concluded
Dec 10 '14 QMWG Meeting QMWG Concluded
Dec 3 '14 WMS Meeting WMS Concluded
Nov 18 '14 QMWG Meeting QMWG Concluded
Nov 6 '14 PRS Meeting PRS Concluded
Oct 29 '14 WMS Meeting WMS Concluded
Oct 9 '14 PRS Meeting PRS Concluded
Sep 23 '14 QMWG Meeting QMWG Concluded