ERCOT·WATCH Search ercot.com  ⌕
NPRR #568 · Revision Request

NPRR568  Real-Time Reserve Price Adder Based on Operating Reserve Demand Curve

Approved Urgent sponsor ERCOT posted 2013-09-19 ercot.com
ReasonTo implement the concepts presented and address concerns raised at the January 24, 2013 PUCT workshop regarding Docket No. 40000.
Created2013-10-18
Approved2013-11-19
Sections Affected
2.12.23.5.2.13.5.2.23.5.2.33.5.2.43.5.2.63.96.36.3.26.4.3.16.4.3.2 (delete)6.4.3.3 (delete)6.5.5.26.5.7.36.5.9.26.6.16.6.1.16.6.1.26.6.3.16.6.106.7.4 (new)6.7.5 (new)8.1.18.1.1.28.1.1.2.18.1.1.2.1.6 (new)8.1.1.2.1.7 (new)8.1.1.4.4 (new)8.1.1.4.5 (new)9.5.3
Summary
This NPRR requires ERCOT to implement an Operating Reserve Demand Curve (ORDC) in the Real-Time Market (RTM) to determine the Real-Time price adder for Real Time Settlement Point Prices. The Real-Time price adder reflects the price for reserves available in the ERCOT System based on the loss of Load probability at that reserve level. The addition of this price adder to the Real Time Settlement Point Price ensures that the Real Time Settlement Point Price reflects the opportunity cost of reserve scarcity. A new Other Binding Document, "Methodology for Implementing Operating Reserve Demand Curve (ORDC) to Calculate Real-Time Reserve Price Adder," a draft of which is attached to this NPRR as Attachment 1, will describe the methodologies for developing the ORDC and determining the reserve price adder using the ORDC. It will also list the values of the parameters to be used. Additional details about the methodology and a backcast based on the methodology can be found in filings under Public Utility Commission of Texas (PUCT) Docket No. 40000, Commission Proceeding to Ensure Resource Adequacy in Texas, and Key Documents posted on the Resource Adequacy Task Force home page . Since Real-Time co-optimization of energy and Ancillary Services will not be implemented at this time, to ensure that Resources are indifferent between providing energy and reserves in Real-Time, an Ancillary Service imbalance Settlement will be performed. Reliability Unit Commitment (RUC) Resources and Reliability Must-Run (RMR) Units are removed from this Ancillary Service imbalance payment for their On-Line capacity in Real-Time since making the payment and clawing it back would result in the same financial outcome but with significant changes to the Protocols.
Action Log 3 milestones
Amendments
DateBodyMotionResult
Oct 18 '13PRS To recommend approval of NPRR568 as amended by the 10/8/13 Morgan Stanley comments, 10/11/13 ERCOT comments, 10/15/13 EMMT comments and 10/16/13 Luminant comments and as revised by PRS with a recommended priority of 2013, rank of 70 and category of Regulatory; to request that the Impact Analysis separate out the impacts associated with each of the following: (A) the 10/11/13 ERCOT comments (including the revision related to Wind-powered Generation Resources introduced in the 10/15/13 EMMT comments), (B) the 10/8/13 Morgan Stanley comments, and (C) the 10/18/13 PRS revisions; to refer the issue of Load Resources providing OFF10 or OFF30 capacity to WMS for assignment to the Demand Side Working Group (DSWG); and to refer review of the verification of Real-Time Production Potential to WMS for assignment to the Qualified Scheduling Entity (QSE) Managers Working Group (QMWG).Passed
Nov 7 '13TAC To recommend approval of the "Methodology for Implementing Operating Reserve Demand Curve (ORDC) to Calculate Real-Time Reserve Price Adder" as amended by the 11/6/13 ERCOT comments (Attachment 1) and as revised by TAC with a proposed effective date of upon implementation of NPRR568 and to add the methodology to the Other Binding Document List.Passed
Documents 26
NameTypePostedClassification
568NPRR-01 Real-Time Reserve Price Adder Based on Operating Rese doc Sep 19 '13 Revision Request
568NPRR-02 Preliminary Impact Analysis 091913 doc Sep 19 '13 Staff Report
568NPRR-03 Attachment 1 - Draft Methodology for Implementing Ope doc Sep 19 '13 Revision Request
568NPRR-04 Morgan Stanley Comments 100813 doc Oct 8 '13 Revision Request Comments
568NPRR-05 Luminant Comments 100913 doc Oct 9 '13 Revision Request Comments
568NPRR-06 Luminant Comments - Attachment 1 100913 doc Oct 9 '13 Revision Request Comments
568NPRR-07 ERCOT Comments 101113 doc Oct 16 '13 Revision Request Comments
568NPRR-08 ERCOT Comments - Attachment 1 101113 doc Oct 11 '13 Revision Request Comments
568NPRR-09 EMMT Comments 101513 doc Oct 15 '13 Revision Request Comments
568NPRR-10 TPS Comments 101513 doc Oct 16 '13 Revision Request Comments
568NPRR-11 EMMT Comments 101613 doc Oct 16 '13 Revision Request Comments
568NPRR-12 EMMT Comments - Attachment 1 101613 doc Oct 16 '13 Revision Request Comments
568NPRR-13 TIEC and CPS Energy Comments 101613 doc Oct 16 '13 Revision Request Comments
568NPRR-14 Luminant Comments 101613 doc Oct 16 '13 Revision Request Comments
568NPRR-15 PRS Report 101813 doc Oct 22 '13 Committee Report
568NPRR-16 Credit Work Group Comments 103113 doc Oct 31 '13 Revision Request Comments
568NPRR-17 Impact Analysis 110513 doc Nov 5 '13 Staff Report
568NPRR-18 ERCOT Comments 110513 doc Nov 5 '13 Revision Request Comments
568NPRR-19 ERCOT Comments - Attachment 1 110513 doc Nov 5 '13 Revision Request Comments
568NPRR-20 ERCOT Comments 110613 doc Nov 6 '13 Revision Request Comments
568NPRR-21 ERCOT Comments - Attachment 1 110613 doc Nov 6 '13 Revision Request Comments
568NPRR-22 TAC Report 110713 doc Nov 8 '13 Committee Report
568NPRR-23 TAC Report - Attachment 1 110713 doc Nov 8 '13 Committee Report
568NPRR-24 TAC Voting Ballot 110713 xls Nov 8 '13 Revision Request Ballot
568NPRR-25 Board Report 111913 doc Nov 19 '13 Committee Report
568NPRR-26 Board Report - Attachment 1 111913 doc Nov 19 '13 Committee Report
Meetings That Took It Up 28
DateMeetingCommitteeStatus
Apr 6 '15 WMS Meeting WMS Concluded
Aug 26 '14 QMWG Meeting QMWG Concluded
Jul 29 '14 QMWG Meeting QMWG Concluded
Jul 9 '14 WMS Meeting WMS Concluded
Jul 1 '14 QMWG Meeting QMWG Concluded
Jun 26 '14 TAC Meeting TAC Concluded
Jun 4 '14 WMS Meeting WMS Concluded
May 29 '14 TAC Meeting TAC Concluded
May 21 '14 QMWG Meeting QMWG Concluded
May 7 '14 WMS Meeting WMS Concluded
May 1 '14 QMWG Meeting QMWG Concluded
Apr 24 '14 TAC Meeting TAC Concluded
Apr 9 '14 WMS Meeting WMS Concluded
Mar 27 '14 TAC Meeting TAC Concluded
Mar 5 '14 WMS Meeting WMS Concluded
Feb 27 '14 TAC Meeting TAC Concluded
Feb 12 '14 COPS Meeting COPS Concluded
Feb 11 '14 Board of Directors Meeting BOARD Concluded
Jan 28 '14 TAC Meeting TAC Concluded
Jan 16 '14 PRS Meeting PRS Concluded
Jan 8 '14 WMS Meeting WMS Concluded
Dec 3 '13 Technical Advisory Committee (TAC) Meeting TAC Concluded
Nov 19 '13 Board of Directors Meeting BOARD Concluded
Nov 7 '13 Technical Advisory Committee (TAC) Meeting TAC Concluded
Oct 30 '13 Joint Credit Working Group (CWG)/Market Credit Working Group (MCWG) Meeting CREDITWG Concluded
Oct 17 '13 Protocol Revision Subcommittee (PRS) Meeting PRS Concluded
Oct 9 '13 Wholesale Market Subcommittee (WMS) Meeting WMS Concluded
Oct 4 '13 RATF Workshop - NPRR568, Real-Time Reserve Price Adder Based on Operating Reserve Demand Curve RATF Concluded