ERCOT·WATCH Search ercot.com  ⌕
NPRR #1235 · Revision Request

NPRR1235  Dispatchable Reliability Reserve Service as a Stand-Alone Ancillary Service

Withdrawn sponsor ERCOT posted 2024-05-29 ercot.com
ReasonRegulatory requirements
Created2024-06-13
Sections Affected
2.12.23.2.33.9.13.17.5 (new)3.184.4.7.14.4.7.24.4.7.34.4.124.5.14.6.2.34.6.2.3.14.6.4.1.6 (new)4.6.4.2.6 (new)5.2.2.25.5.25.6.25.7.15.7.1.15.7.1.25.7.25.7.45.7.4.1 (new)5.7.4.15.7.4.1.1 (new)5.7.4.1.2 (new)5.7.4.1.25.7.4.26.16.5.5.26.5.7.3.16.5.7.56.5.7.6.2.5 (new)6.7.4 (new)6.7.4.1 (new)6.7.4.2 (new)6.7.48.1.1.2.1.8 (new)8.1.1.4.5 (new)9.2.39.5.39.14.10and 16.11.4.3.1
Summary
This Nodal Protocol Revision Request (NPRR) develops a stand-alone Dispatchable Reliability Reserve Service (DRRS) product that includes the following functionality: DRRS is added to the Protocols on top of Real-Time Co-optimization (RTC) and Energy Storage Resource (ESR) single-model Protocols; DRRS is offered, awarded, and paid in the Day-Ahead Market (DAM). DRRS is not co-optimized in the Real-Time Market (RTM); DRRS can be-self arranged and traded. However, there are no DRRS-only offers (i.e., virtual DRRS offers) allowed, as DRRS will not be co-optimized in Real-Time; DRRS can be provided by Off-Line Generation Resources; a new Resource Status code will be developed for Resources with an Ancillary Service Resource Responsibility for DRRS that have not been deployed by ERCOT; When looking to commit capacity during the Reliability Unit Commitment (RUC) process, RUC will give priority to committing Off-Line Generation Resources providing DRRS. This is accomplished because Off-Line DRRS Resources will appear to have lower start-up and minimum energy costs relative to other Off-Line Generation Resources in the RUC optimization; DRRS will have a failure-to-provide Settlement for Qualified Scheduling Entities (QSEs) that do not sufficiently preserve Resource capability for providing DRRS within their portfolio; DRRS deployments will be included in the Reliability Deployment Price Adder process, in alignment with other existing Protocol language for similar deployments; and QSEs that are short on their DRRS Supply Responsibility at the time of a RUC instruction will be allocated a portion of any RUC Make Whole charges prior to allocating those costs to the QSEs that are RUC Capacity Short.
Action Log 1 milestones
Ballots
DateBodyResultYesNoAbstain
Aug 1 '24 ROS Motion Carries 7 0 7 xls
Jul 11 '24 ROS Motion Carries 7.5 0 0 xls
Jun 13 '24 PRS Motion Carries 7 0 0 xls
Documents 22
NameTypePostedClassification
1235NPRR-01 Dispatchable Reliability Reserve Service as a Stand-Alone Ancillary Service 052924 docx May 29 '24 Revision Request
1235NPRR-02 Preliminary Impact Analysis 052924 docx May 29 '24 Staff Report
1235NPRR-03 Sierra Club Comments 060324 docx Jun 3 '24 Revision Request Comments
1235NPRR-04 PRS Ballot 061324 xls Jun 18 '24 Revision Request Ballot
1235NPRR-05 PRS Report 061324 docx Jun 18 '24 Committee Report
1235NPRR-06 Sierra Club Comments 070624 docx Jul 6 '24 Revision Request Comments
1235NPRR-07 WMS Comments 071124 docx Jul 11 '24 Revision Request Comments
1235NPRR-08 ROS Comments 071124 docx Jul 11 '24 Revision Request Comments
1235NPRR-09 TSPA Comments 071524 docx Jul 15 '24 Revision Request Comments
1235NPRR-10 Joint Commenters Comments 072224 docx Jul 22 '24 Revision Request Comments
1235NPRR-11 ROS Ballot 080124 xls Aug 1 '24 Revision Request Ballot
1235NPRR-12 ROS Comments 080124 docx Aug 1 '24 Revision Request Comments
1235NPRR-13 Joint Commenters Comments 080724 docx Aug 7 '24 Revision Request Comments
1235NPRR-14 ERCOT Comments 082324 docx Aug 23 '24 Revision Request Comments
1235NPRR-15 IMM Comments 091124 docx Sep 11 '24 Revision Request Comments
1235NPRR-16 Luminant Comments 092324 docx Sep 23 '24 Revision Request Comments
1235NPRR-17 APA Comments 092424 docx Sep 24 '24 Revision Request Comments
1235NPRR-18 ERCOT Comments 100124 docx Oct 1 '24 Revision Request Comments
1235NPRR-19 Luminant Comments 111324 docx Nov 13 '24 Revision Request Comments
1235NPRR-20 IMM Comments 112024 docx Nov 20 '24 Revision Request Comments
1235NPRR-21 IMM Comments 122024 docx Dec 20 '24 Revision Request Comments
1235NPRR-22 Request for Withdrawal 112025 docx Nov 20 '25 Revision Request
Meetings That Took It Up 59
DateMeetingCommitteeStatus
Jan 21 '26 TAC Meeting TAC Concluded
Dec 10 '25 PRS Meeting PRS Concluded
Dec 3 '25 WMS Meeting - Webex Only WMS Concluded
Nov 19 '25 TAC Meeting TAC Concluded
Nov 12 '25 PRS Meeting PRS Concluded
Nov 5 '25 WMS Meeting WMS Concluded
Oct 22 '25 TAC Meeting TAC Concluded
Oct 8 '25 PRS Meeting PRS Concluded
Oct 3 '25 WMS Meeting WMS Concluded
Sep 17 '25 PRS Meeting PRS Concluded
Sep 10 '25 WMS Meeting WMS Concluded
Aug 27 '25 TAC Meeting TAC Concluded
Aug 13 '25 PRS Meeting PRS Concluded
Aug 6 '25 WMS Meeting - Webex Only WMS Concluded
Jul 30 '25 TAC Meeting - Webex Only TAC Concluded
Jul 16 '25 PRS Meeting PRS Concluded
Jul 9 '25 WMS Meeting WMS Concluded
Jun 11 '25 PRS Meeting PRS Concluded
Jun 4 '25 WMS Meeting - Webex Only WMS Concluded
May 28 '25 TAC Meeting - Webex Only TAC Concluded
May 14 '25 PRS Meeting PRS Concluded
May 7 '25 WMS Meeting WMS Concluded
Apr 23 '25 TAC Meeting TAC Concluded
Apr 9 '25 PRS Meeting PRS Concluded
Apr 2 '25 WMS Meeting WMS Concluded
Mar 26 '25 TAC Meeting TAC Concluded
Mar 12 '25 PRS Meeting PRS Concluded
Mar 5 '25 WMS Meeting - Webex Only WMS Concluded
Feb 27 '25 TAC Meeting TAC Concluded
Feb 12 '25 PRS Meeting PRS Concluded
Feb 5 '25 WMS Meeting WMS Concluded
Jan 22 '25 TAC Meeting - Webex Only TAC Concluded
Jan 15 '25 PRS Meeting PRS Concluded
Jan 8 '25 WMS Meeting - Webex Only WMS Concluded
Dec 12 '24 PRS Meeting PRS Concluded
Dec 4 '24 WMS Meeting WMS Concluded
Nov 20 '24 TAC Meeting TAC Concluded
Nov 14 '24 PRS Meeting PRS Concluded
Nov 6 '24 WMS Meeting WMS Concluded
Oct 30 '24 TAC Meeting - Webex Only TAC Concluded
Oct 18 '24 WMWG Meeting - Webex Only WMWG Concluded
Oct 17 '24 PRS Meeting PRS Concluded
Oct 7 '24 WMS Meeting - Webex Only WMS Concluded
Sep 24 '24 WMWG Meeting - Webex Only WMWG Concluded
Sep 19 '24 TAC Meeting TAC Concluded
Sep 12 '24 PRS Meeting PRS Concluded
Sep 11 '24 WMS Meeting WMS Concluded
Sep 9 '24 ROS Meeting - Webex Only ROS Concluded
Aug 30 '24 WMWG Meeting - Webex Only WMWG Concluded
Aug 26 '24 SAWG Meeting - Webex Only SAWG Concluded
Aug 8 '24 PRS Meeting PRS Concluded
Aug 7 '24 WMS Meeting WMS Concluded
Aug 1 '24 ROS Meeting - Webex Only ROS Concluded
Jul 24 '24 PDCWG Meeting PDCWG Concluded
Jul 23 '24 WMWG Meeting - Webex Only WMWG Concluded
Jul 18 '24 PRS Meeting - Webex Only PRS Concluded
Jul 11 '24 ROS Meeting - Webex Only ROS Concluded
Jul 10 '24 WMS Meeting - Webex Only WMS Concluded
Jun 13 '24 PRS Meeting PRS Concluded