ERCOT·WATCH Search ercot.com  ⌕
NPRR #1214 · Revision Request

NPRR1214  Reliability Deployment Price Adder Fix to Provide Locational Price Signals, Reduce Uplift and Risk

Pending sponsor Joint Sponsors posted 2023-12-07 next PRS for consideration (PRS) ercot.com
ReasonStrategic Plan Objective 2
Created2024-01-11
Sections Affected
2.13.2.53.5.2.13.5.2.23.5.2.33.5.2.43.5.2.53.5.2.63.5.2.74.4.115.5.25.7.1.35.7.1.46.3.26.5.7.36.5.7.3.16.5.9.26.6.1.16.6.1.26.6.1.66.6.1.7 (delete)6.6.3.16.6.3.66.6.3.86.6.6.36.6.6.106.7.56.7.66.9 (new)6.9.1 (new)6.9.2 (new)and 9.5.3
Summary
This Nodal Protocol Revision Request (NPRR) revises the Real-Time On-Line Reliability Deployment Price Adder (RTRDPA) to: send appropriate locational price signals to avoid counterproductive Load and Resource responses to RTRDPA price signals under Real-Time Co-optimization (RTC); limit Resource payment to the actual “indifference payment” (consistent with its definition), thereby reducing associated uplift by eliminating the future need for RTRDPA payments to Resources that exacerbate constraints and eliminating payments to available capacity not requiring an indifference payment; eliminate any future need for the Ancillary Service Imbalance Payments or Charges (ASIP/C) type of indifference payment associated with RTRDPA, thereby reducing the risk associated with providing Ancillary Services; provide Resources an indifference payment under RTC to eliminate the potentially large incentive to ignore Base Point instructions that would likely cause serious reliability issues; and provide a stronger locational price signal around Resources committed by the Reliability Unit Commitment (RUC) process or other reliability actions for congestion, thereby reducing RUC Make-Whole Payment-related charges and uplifts and appropriately compensating impacted Qualified Scheduling Entities (QSEs).
Action Log 5 milestones
Amendments
DateBodyMotionResult
Mar 12 '25PRS To recommend approval of NPRR1214 as amended by the 1/28/25 ERCOT commentsPassed
Jun 10 '26PRS To endorse the 5/14/25 PRS Report as amended by the 6/5/26 ERCOT comments for NPRR1214; and to bring the Revised Impact Analysis back to PRSPassed
Ballots
DateBodyResultYesNoAbstain
Jun 10 '26 PRS Motion Carries 7 0 0 xls
May 14 '25 PRS Motion Carries 7 0 0 xls
Apr 9 '25 PRS Motion Carries 7 0 0 xls
Mar 12 '25 PRS Motion Carries 7 0 0 xls
Mar 5 '25 WMS Motion Carries 7.5 0 0 xls
Feb 7 '24 WMS Motion Carries 7.5 0 0 xls
Jan 11 '24 PRS Motion Carries 7 0 0 xls
Documents 25
NameTypePostedClassification
1214NPRR-01 Reliability Deployment Price Adder Fix to Provide Locational Price Signals, Reduce Uplift and Risk 120723 docx Dec 7 '23 Revision Request
1214NPRR-02 PRS Ballot 011124 xls Jan 16 '24 Revision Request Ballot
1214NPRR-03 PRS Report 011124 docx Jan 16 '24 Committee Report
1214NPRR-04 WMS Ballot 020724 xls Feb 8 '24 Revision Request Ballot
1214NPRR-05 WMS Comments 020824 doc Feb 8 '24 Revision Request Comments
1214NPRR-06 ERCOT Comments 080924 docx Aug 9 '24 Revision Request Comments
1214NPRR-07 Joint Sponsors Comments 110424 docx Nov 4 '24 Revision Request Comments
1214NPRR-08 ERCOT Comments 012825 docx Jan 28 '25 Revision Request Comments
1214NPRR-09 WMS Ballot 030525 xls Mar 6 '25 Revision Request Ballot
1214NPRR-10 WMS Comments 030625 doc Mar 6 '25 Revision Request Comments
1214NPRR-11 PRS Ballot 031225 xls Mar 17 '25 Revision Request Ballot
1214NPRR-12 PRS Report 031225 docx Mar 17 '25 Committee Report
1214NPRR-13 ERCOT Comments 033125 docx Mar 31 '25 Revision Request Comments
1214NPRR-14 PRS Ballot 040925 xls Apr 11 '25 Revision Request Ballot
1214NPRR-15 PRS Report 040925 docx Apr 11 '25 Committee Report
1214NPRR-16 Impact Analysis 051325 docx May 13 '25 Staff Report
1214NPRR-17 PRS Ballot 051425 xls May 17 '25 Revision Request Ballot
1214NPRR-18 PRS Report 051425 docx May 17 '25 Committee Report
1214NPRR-19 Vitol Comments 052826 docx May 28 '26 Revision Request Comments
1214NPRR-20 ERCOT Comments 052926 docx May 29 '26 Revision Request Comments
1214NPRR-21 ERCOT Comments 060526 docx Jun 5 '26 Revision Request Comments
1214NPRR-22 PRS Ballot 061026 xls Jun 10 '26 Revision Request Ballot
1214NPRR-23 PRS Report 061026 docx Jun 10 '26 Committee Report
1214NPRR-24 IMM Comments 062226 docx Jun 22 '26 Revision Request Comments
1214NPRR-25 ERCOT Comments 070926 docx Jul 9 '26 Revision Request Comments
Meetings That Took It Up 50
DateMeetingCommitteeStatus
Jul 15 '26 PRS Meeting PRS Scheduled
Jun 10 '26 PRS Meeting PRS Concluded
May 6 '26 PRS Meeting PRS Concluded
Apr 15 '26 PRS Meeting PRS Concluded
Mar 11 '26 PRS Meeting PRS Concluded
Feb 11 '26 PRS Meeting PRS Concluded
Jan 14 '26 PRS Meeting PRS Concluded
Dec 10 '25 PRS Meeting PRS Concluded
Nov 12 '25 PRS Meeting PRS Concluded
Oct 8 '25 PRS Meeting PRS Concluded
Sep 17 '25 PRS Meeting PRS Concluded
Aug 13 '25 PRS Meeting PRS Concluded
Jul 16 '25 PRS Meeting PRS Concluded
Jun 11 '25 PRS Meeting PRS Concluded
May 14 '25 PRS Meeting PRS Concluded
Apr 9 '25 PRS Meeting PRS Concluded
Mar 12 '25 PRS Meeting PRS Concluded
Mar 5 '25 WMS Meeting - Webex Only WMS Concluded
Feb 18 '25 CMWG Meeting - Webex Only CMWG Concluded
Feb 12 '25 PRS Meeting PRS Concluded
Feb 5 '25 WMS Meeting WMS Concluded
Jan 15 '25 PRS Meeting PRS Concluded
Jan 8 '25 WMS Meeting - Webex Only WMS Concluded
Dec 12 '24 PRS Meeting PRS Concluded
Dec 6 '24 CMWG Meeting - Webex Only CMWG Concluded
Dec 4 '24 WMS Meeting WMS Concluded
Nov 14 '24 PRS Meeting PRS Concluded
Nov 6 '24 WMS Meeting WMS Concluded
Oct 17 '24 PRS Meeting PRS Concluded
Oct 14 '24 CMWG Meeting - Webex Only CMWG Concluded
Oct 7 '24 WMS Meeting - Webex Only WMS Concluded
Sep 23 '24 CMWG Meeting - Webex Only CMWG Concluded
Sep 12 '24 PRS Meeting PRS Concluded
Sep 11 '24 WMS Meeting WMS Concluded
Aug 8 '24 PRS Meeting PRS Concluded
Aug 7 '24 WMS Meeting WMS Concluded
Jul 18 '24 PRS Meeting - Webex Only PRS Concluded
Jul 10 '24 WMS Meeting - Webex Only WMS Concluded
Jun 13 '24 PRS Meeting PRS Concluded
Jun 5 '24 WMS Meeting WMS Concluded
May 9 '24 PRS Meeting PRS Concluded
May 1 '24 WMS Meeting - Webex Only WMS Concluded
Apr 5 '24 PRS Meeting - Webex Only PRS Concluded
Apr 3 '24 WMS Meeting WMS Concluded
Mar 25 '24 CMWG Meeting - Webex Only CMWG Concluded
Mar 20 '24 PRS Meeting PRS Concluded
Mar 6 '24 WMS Meeting WMS Concluded
Feb 8 '24 PRS Meeting PRS Concluded
Feb 7 '24 WMS Meeting WMS Concluded
Jan 11 '24 PRS Meeting PRS Concluded