NPRR #1034 · Revision Request
NPRR1034 Frequency-Based Limits on DC Tie Imports or Exports
ReasonRegulatory requirements: This NPRR is proposed in accordance with the May 23, 2017, order of the Public Utility Commission of Texas (PUCT) in Project No. 46304, Oversight Proceeding Regarding ERCOT Matters Arising Out of PUC Docket No. 45624 Relating to DC Tie Project Proposed by Southern Cross Transmission, LLC, which requires ERCOT to address a number of issues as a condition for the energization of the DC Tie project proposed by Southern Cross Transmission LLC (“Southern Cross Transmission”). As proposed, the Southern Cross DC Tie would be capable of importing 2,000 MW or exporting 2,100 MW. The PUCT’s Directive 9 in the order requires ERCOT to “evaluate what modifications to existing and additional Ancillary Services, if any, are necessary for the reliable interconnection of the Southern Cross DC tie.” ERCOT’s studies evaluating the potential need for Ancillary Services associated with the Southern Cross DC Tie identified a risk of unacceptable frequency overshoot in the event of the loss of the Southern Cross DC Tie when exporting above certain levels under certain operating conditions. ERCOT’s evaluation further identified likely future procurement of incremental Ancillary Services as a means to address the frequency overshoot concern. Southern Cross Transmission proposes this NPRR as a more efficient solution for the entire market by establishing limits on certain DC Tie transfers when necessary to address the risk of frequency overshoot, rather than requiring procurement of additional Ancillary Services.
Created2020-08-13
Approved2021-02-09
Sections Affected
4.4.4 and 4.4.4.3 (new)
Summary
This Nodal Protocol Revision Request (NPRR) creates new Protocol Section 4.4.4.3, Frequency-Based Limits on DC Tie Imports or Exports to allow ERCOT to establish import or export limits on Direct Current Ties (DC Ties) to avoid the risk of any unacceptable frequency deviation that may be identified in the event of an unexpected loss of one or more DC Ties when importing or exporting. Revisions to Section 4.4.4, DC Tie Schedules, would allow ERCOT to curtail DC Tie Schedules on a DC Tie on a last-in-first-out basis when necessary to address this risk. The last-in-first-out curtailment methodology is consistent with current practice documented in the ERCOT DC Tie Operating Procedure Manual. ERCOT would be required to post on the Market Information System (MIS) Public Area the operating conditions and associated limits that it would expect to use.
Action Log 6 milestones
-
Aug 13
PRSDeferred/Tabled→ Language Consideration
-
Nov 11
PRSRecommended for Approval→ Impact Analysis Consideration
-
Dec 10
PRSDeferred/Tabled→ Impact Analysis Consideration
-
Jan 14
PRSRecommended for Approval→ Revision Request Consideration
-
Jan 27
TACRecommended for Approval→ Revision Request Consideration
-
Feb 9
BOARDApproved
Amendments
| Date | Body | Motion | Result |
|---|---|---|---|
| Nov 11 '20 | PRS | to recommend approval of NPRR1034 as amended by the 10/22/20 SCT comments | Passed |
| Jan 27 '21 | TAC | to recommend approval of NPRR1034 as recommended by PRS in the 1/14/21 PRS Report as amended by the 1/25/21 ERCOT comments. | Passed |
Ballots
| Date | Body | Result | Yes | No | Abstain | |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Jan 27 '21 | TAC | Motion Passes | 30 | 0 | 0 | xls |
| Jan 14 '21 | PRS | Motion Carries | 7 | 0 | 1 | xls |
| Dec 10 '20 | PRS | — | 27 | 0 | 0 | xls |
| Nov 11 '20 | PRS | Motion Carries | 7 | 0 | 0 | xls |
| Nov 5 '20 | ROS | Motion Carries | 7.5 | 0 | 0 | xls |
| Sep 3 '20 | ROS | Motion Carries | 7.5 | 0 | 0 | xls |
Documents 20
| Name | Type | Posted | Classification |
|---|---|---|---|
| 1034NPRR-01 Frequency Based Limits on DC Tie Imports or Exports 072220 | doc | Jul 22 '20 | Revision Request |
| 1034NPRR-02 PRS Ballot 081320 | xls | Aug 18 '20 | Revision Request Ballot |
| 1034NPRR-03 PRS Report 081320 | doc | Aug 18 '20 | Committee Report |
| 1034NPRR-04 ROS Ballot 090320 | xls | Sep 9 '20 | Revision Request Ballot |
| 1034NPRR-05 ROS Comments 090920 | doc | Sep 9 '20 | Revision Request Comments |
| 1034NPRR-06 SCT Comments 102220 | doc | Oct 22 '20 | Revision Request Comments |
| 1034NPRR-07 ROS Ballot 110520 | xls | Nov 9 '20 | Revision Request Ballot |
| 1034NPRR-08 ROS Comments 110920 | doc | Nov 9 '20 | Revision Request Comments |
| 1034NPRR-09 PRS Ballot 111120 | xls | Nov 16 '20 | Revision Request Ballot |
| 1034NPRR-10 PRS Report 111120 | doc | Nov 16 '20 | Committee Report |
| 1034NPRR-11 ERCOT Comments 120920 | doc | Dec 9 '20 | Revision Request Comments |
| 1034NPRR-12 PRS Ballot 121020 | xls | Dec 15 '20 | Revision Request Ballot |
| 1034NPRR-13 PRS Report 121020 | doc | Dec 15 '20 | Committee Report |
| 1034NPRR-14 Impact Analysis 121520 | docx | Dec 15 '20 | Staff Report |
| 1034NPRR-15 PRS Ballot 011421 | xls | Jan 20 '21 | Revision Request Ballot |
| 1034NPRR-16 PRS Report 011421 | doc | Jan 20 '21 | Committee Report |
| 1034NPRR-17 ERCOT Comments 012521 | doc | Jan 25 '21 | Revision Request Comments |
| 1034NPRR-18 TAC Ballot 012721 | xls | Feb 1 '21 | Revision Request Ballot |
| 1034NPRR-19 TAC Report 012721 | doc | Feb 1 '21 | Committee Report |
| 1034NPRR-20 Board Report 020921 | doc | Feb 12 '21 | Committee Report |
Meetings That Took It Up 13
| Date | Meeting | Committee | Status |
|---|---|---|---|
| Jun 16 '21 | PDCWG Meeting by Webex Only | PDCWG | Concluded |
| May 14 '21 | PDCWG Meeting by Webex Only | PDCWG | Concluded |
| Feb 9 '21 | Urgent Board of Directors Meeting – Teleconference Available by Webcast | BOARD | Concluded |
| Jan 27 '21 | TAC Meeting by Webex Only | TAC | Concluded |
| Jan 14 '21 | PRS Meeting by Webex Only | PRS | Concluded |
| Dec 10 '20 | PRS Meeting by Webex Only | PRS | Concluded |
| Nov 11 '20 | PRS Meeting by Webex Only | PRS | Concluded |
| Nov 5 '20 | ROS Meeting by Webex Only | ROS | Concluded |
| Oct 15 '20 | PRS Meeting by Webex Only | PRS | Concluded |
| Oct 8 '20 | ROS Meeting by Webex Only | ROS | Concluded |
| Sep 10 '20 | PRS Meeting | PRS | Concluded |
| Sep 3 '20 | ROS Meeting | ROS | Concluded |
| Aug 13 '20 | PRS Meeting | PRS | Concluded |